Firstly, as the 10 contestants and Blaineley were heading to the film lot, the train they were in, stalled and everyone was put to sleep. When they woke up, Blaineley was missing (supposedly kidnapped). Dawn realises she can read everyone except Noah, making him a prime suspect of the kidnapping. They investigated the film lot and then the murders began. Beth would have been the first victim. She won TDA, so I felt it was fair she went down first. Cody would have been the first chapter's protagonist and learns that despite getting engaged to Brady next month, Beth still harboured feelings for him. The mastermind had found that out and was disgusted by her two-timing nature and thus kills her first. A mysterious host (A bloodied Mr Coconut) rolls out and told them to find how the murder happened or else they would be the next victim, so each person had to fight for his or her self. Each person can only visit one 3 places: the crime scene, the last known whereabouts or the morgue to see the victim’s body (adapted from Who Dunnit). During the investigation, Noah was selfish and shared his info exclusively with Katie and Eva (each went to a different place). Thus the 9 students split into two groups. Noah with Katie, Eva and Brick (Brick joined in later because he impressed Noah with his conclusion). Meanwhile, Dawn was left with Trent, Anne Maria, B and Cody. Anne Maria initially tried to nose her way into Noah’s group but failed and was mad that she was in the dumber group. Trent and Katie were dating (hinted in TDA), so Trent tried to get her to come to his side. Katie wasn’t sure what to do, so she declined. Dawn persuaded Katie to keep an eye on Noah. Noah's team had the upper hand and Trent felt he did badly and would be the next victim.
Beth received a text that Cody was kidnapped in the studio. She wore a tiki mask, a bathrobe and stole a gun to confront the mastermind and rescue her crush, but she got shot on the head right through with a bow and arrow, which breaks a mirror. The killer removed the bathrobe (with the gun inside) to wipe the blood and stashed it in the laundromat. Then the killer moved her body using the mat against the mirror. Then the mastermind hid the bow and arrow in an umbrella pot.